Get a free sample

YouTube growth in 2026, according to 850 Reddit threads

What creators actually earn, what moved their numbers and what got channels banned, in their own words. 172,000 posts scanned, 850 threads read in full, 4,915 facts checked word-for-word against the source.

How this was made. Our collector scanned about 172,000 Reddit posts, picked the 850 most active threads about growing and earning on YouTube, and read them in full with comments. 4,915 individual facts were extracted, and every quote was checked word-for-word against the original (5 failed and were dropped). These are creators' own accounts, not an audit: where people disagree, we say so. Every line links to its thread.

YouTube pays for minutes, not niches

The most sobering table of the whole study came from a creator in r/PartneredYoutube: three videos with almost the same views. An 11-minute video with 71K views earned $708, a 23-minute video with 72K earned $877, and a 30-second Short with 79K views earned $10 r/PartneredYoutube ↑2 · 2025-11-02. Going further, a 91-minute video showed an RPM of $11.39 and a two-and-a-half-hour one almost $14, because more mid-rolls fit in r/PartneredYoutube ↑10 · 2026-09-21.

Subscribers barely matter. A 330K channel makes about $800 a month r/PartneredYoutube ↑113 · 2025-01-11, while a 12K channel with one long video a week makes around $3,500 r/PartneredYoutube ↑14 · 2026-05-28.

Shorts: 100 million views, $1,100

“One of my Shorts hit 100 million views. I made $1100 from that video.”

That post collected 552 upvotes r/PartneredYoutube ↑552 · 2025-09-10. Since August 2026 creators also report a hard threshold: Shorts pay only to channels with 10 million engaged views over a rolling 90 days. A gaming channel with 8.6 million fell out of Shorts monetization entirely r/PartneredYoutube ↑103 · 2026-08-15, and creators below the line say they're losing $800+ a month r/PartneredYoutube ↑24 · 2026-08-30. We found this rule only in creators' retellings, not in an official YouTube document.

A community trick: for a Shorts creator, the easier way into the Partner Program is a single long video. A 6:30 video got one creator monetized, while a Short with 20 million views didn't help. The same creator re-uploaded a flopped Short unchanged as a horizontal video under 3 minutes, and it got about 70K views r/NewTubers ↑231 · 2026-08-02.

The mystery: who ate the views in autumn 2025?

Hundreds of creators complained: from 10 August 2025, desktop views collapsed. One gaming channel saw its desktop share fall from 58% to 26% r/PartneredYoutube ↑5 · 2025-09-13. The most convincing explanation in the threads isn't the algorithm but uBlock Origin: an update started blocking telemetry, so views stopped being counted, while AdSense revenue barely changed r/PartneredYoutube ↑120 · 2025-12-10.

That's not the whole story, though. From 25 September some channels saw Browse traffic drop by 80% r/PartneredYoutube ↑160 · 2025-12-10, and the home page went from 8–10 long-form thumbnails to 3–4 plus a Shorts shelf r/PartneredYoutube ↑20 · 2025-11-04. The eeriest observation of the year: a channel where every metric grew for 12 months straight (average view duration 5:35 → 8:17, CTR 4.2% → 5.5%) while views kept falling r/PartneredYoutube ↑495 · 2025-05-15.

What worked, with numbers

Niches: where the money is

Finance still wears the crown: from $2–4 on general videos to $100+ on narrow ones r/sidehustle ↑622 · 2024-12-05. A million-view gaming video earned $3.7K; the same in finance, the creator estimates, would have made $15–20K r/NewTubers ↑11 · 2025-10-22.

The surprise dark horse is gardening: an RPM around $15, and $15–18K in 28 days on 1.1 million views r/youtubers ↑5 · 2022-10-08. Then prepping, with an RPM of about $19 on a US audience aged 35+ r/NewTubers ↑22 · 2026-02-11. Narrow hobbies take off fast: a ham-radio channel gained 8,000 subscribers in 11 days r/NewTubers ↑3 · 2026-01-11.

The richest lesson: AdSense often isn't the main income at all. One affiliate review brought in $20,000+ against about $1,000 a year in AdSense r/PartneredYoutube ↑180 · 2025-12-24. A 230K education channel makes $1,200 from ads and $25,000 a month from the business around the channel r/Entrepreneur ↑196 · 2024-07-11.

AI channels: fool's gold?

The bait story: two people launched the same idea, one fully with AI, the other by hand.

“Now they have close to 300 million views, I have 60K.”

r/NewTubers ↑65 · 2026-04-12. A Kapwing count discussed on Reddit puts 278 AI-slop channels in the top 15,000 at about $117 million a year r/youtube ↑18 · 2026-03-21. The flip side: the channel Epic-Sports-Tales uploaded 11,547 videos and averaged about 7 views each r/PartneredYoutube ↑4 · 2025-06-30, and roughly 80% of AI clips never get reach r/passive_income ↑2 · 2026-05-20.

Since March 2026 YouTube has been asking viewers "Does this feel like AI slop?" r/youtube ↑18 · 2026-03-21, and in January thousands of channels lost monetization within two days for reused content r/NewTubers ↑379 · 2026-01-08. The key nuance: the platform punishes templated, repetitive content, not AI as such. A 3D animator who shows his face in tutorials got caught too r/youtube ↑1153 · 2026-03-18.

Incident report

  • Scheduled a month of Shorts, lost the channel. Uploading 30+ Shorts as drafts in one day looked like a spam farm: a $2K/month channel was demonetized, with losses over $10,000 r/PartneredYoutube ↑41 · 2026-08-24.
  • Banned by association. A brother's channel was banned; the same day the poster's 200K channel and even their mother's channel were removed. Commenters suspect a shared home IP r/youtube ↑234 · 2026-07-08.
  • The fake sponsor. A "contract" attachment steals the session and bypasses 2FA; channels with 178K and 340K were hijacked this way. After recovery, check the channel's managers: attackers leave a back door r/PartneredYoutube ↑111 · 2025-01-28.
  • Promoting a channel with Google Ads brings ghost subscribers: 0.31 seconds of watch time vs 4–8 minutes from organic viewers r/NewTubers ↑1 · 2026-02-20.
  • A lawyer and the EU's Digital Services Act restored 6 banned channels in under a day for €800 r/PartneredYoutube ↑219 · 2026-08-24.

Kids' content: the parents' view

This was the largest block of the study, over a thousand facts, and almost all of it was written by parents, not creators. That makes it valuable: it's the buyer's voice.

The community's verdict: mass-produced AI kids' content, no: the space is crowded, parents are building walls and the platform demonetizes. Classic Cocomelon-style content, also no: Moonbug and hundreds of clones own it. A narrow yes: calm content parents trust, with slow pacing, an expert format in the spirit of Ms Rachel, or classroom brain breaks. The goal is a place on the parent's whitelist and income from the brand, not from ads.

10 insights in one line each

  1. Video length and mid-rolls move revenue more than the choice of niche.
  2. Shorts are a shop window, not a till: $80–215 per million views, and payouts only above 10M engaged views in 90 days.
  3. The first sentence and the first 10 seconds decide a video's fate more than editing does.
  4. CTR is secondary: YouTube promotes watch depth, and even thumbnail A/B tests are judged by watch time.
  5. The 2025 drop was partly a counting illusion (ad blockers), partly a real cut to the home page.
  6. The platform punishes templates and volume, not AI: AI-assisted lives, AI farms don't.
  7. The money sits next to the channel: affiliate deals, products and sponsors pay many times more than AdSense.
  8. Accounts are linked: a ban or demonetization on one channel can hit every channel the owner has.
  9. In kids' content the parent with a whitelist decides, not the algorithm.
  10. The most reliable fresh niches are boring: gardening, home, prepping, search-driven education, narrow hobbies.

What we didn't find

No official YouTube texts: the new 2027 thresholds and the 10M/90-day rule are known only from creators' retellings. Almost no numbers for beauty, fitness, crypto or real estate, and no production costs for AI-made cartoons. The Reddit archive was slow during the run, so some evergreen searches in r/PartneredYoutube before 2025 and in seven general business subreddits were skipped; the core creator subreddits are covered in full for 2025–2026.

Want a report like this about your market? Tell us your question and get a free sample within 24 hours. Start here →
Get a free sample →